Signed in as:
filler@godaddy.com
Signed in as:
filler@godaddy.com

Author: Dr. John Bruni
Title: Founder and CEO, SAGE International
11 November 2026 | 3-minute read
In an increasingly interconnected world, strategic risks do not always emerge through sudden crises or open confrontation. They can develop gradually through repeated disruptions, shifting dependencies and incremental constraints on institutional decision-making. Understanding these dynamics is essential for governments, businesses and investors seeking to strengthen resilience, preserve strategic autonomy and navigate an increasingly complex geopolitical and economic environment.
Published as part of ITT Nexus’s Invited Expert Perspectives series, this contribution by Dr. John Bruni, Founder and CEO of SAGE International, examines Threshold Conditioning™, a conceptual framework to explore how sustained pressure can reshape perceptions of risk, influence strategic responses and progressively narrow the choices available to decision-makers.
Drawing connections between national security, critical infrastructure, economic interdependence and institutional preparedness, his analysis contributes to the broader discussion on geopolitical risk, geoeconomic resilience and strategic foresight, highlighting the importance of recognizing emerging vulnerabilities before they develop into full-scale crises.
ITT Nexus welcomes this contribution as part of its commitment to fostering independent, research-informed dialogue on geopolitical risk, geoeconomic resilience, critical infrastructure, institutional preparedness and strategic foresight, with particular attention to the evolving security and economic dynamics shaping the Gulf, the Global South and the wider international system.
By Dr. John Bruni
11 November 2026
---------------------------------------
A crisis usually announces itself through an unmistakable event: a shipping route closes, key services fail, or a government receives an ultimatum.
Yet the strategic balance may have shifted long before that moment.
Decisions have been delayed, dependencies deepened and intrusions tolerated. When leaders recognise the emergency, they may find several preferred responses no longer practical.
The difficulty is that these changes rarely arrive together.
Each disruption has its own explanation, responsible authority and proposed solution.
Officials can manage individual incidents competently while overlooking their combined effect. The immediate problem is contained, but the country or organisation gradually loses room to act.
This process is explored through Threshold Conditioning™ (TC), a conceptual framework developed by SAGE International. It analyses how repeated coercive pressure changes what a target considers normal, acceptable or worth resisting.
The central question is clear: what freedom of action is being lost before anyone declares a crisis?
When the exceptional becomes routine
A threshold is the point at which an event is considered serious enough to require a response.
Such points are rarely fixed.
Decisions depend on evidence, legal authority, available resources, political agreement and the likely consequences of action. Repeated pressure can exploit these conditions without producing a single event that demands an immediate, decisive response.
Consider a hypothetical shipping route affected by recurring interference.
Initially, operators expect normal access to return. Later, they adjust schedules, absorb additional costs and reduce services. Customers make other arrangements. Eventually, restricted access becomes an accepted operating condition, even though no formal closure has occurred.
Adaptation keeps commerce moving, but it may also conceal a strategic loss.
The relevant question is whether operators retain workable choices or have become dependent on conditions set by another actor. A short-term adjustment becomes consequential when reversing it is increasingly difficult.
This overlaps with “grey-zone competition”, meaning confrontation below open warfare, and “hybrid threats”, which combine different forms of pressure.
TC draws attention to a particular relationship: repeated activity changes expectations and behaviour, possibly making further coercion easier. Its value depends on demonstrating that relationship rather than simply applying a new label to disruption.
Security and commercial confidence
For the UAE and other Gulf economies, this issue connects national security with everyday commercial decisions.
Trade, aviation, energy, finance and digital services depend on reliable access.
A country does not have to face invasion for uncertainty about these connections to affect its prosperity and independence.
Imagine selective delays to critical imports occurring alongside unreliable communications and restrictions on technical support. A ministry, telecommunications operator and private supplier might each investigate separately. Together, however, the disruptions could delay a major project or make an alternative policy harder to implement. This is an illustrative scenario, not evidence of a particular campaign.
The danger is greatest where apparent alternatives share the same dependency. Two suppliers may rely on one component manufacturer. Separate digital services may depend on the same infrastructure. A contingency plan offers limited reassurance if its backup fails under the same conditions as the primary arrangement.
The relationship between commitments and available capacity matters just as much.
Equipment, financial resources and partnerships provide options only when they can be used in time and sustained. Repeated demands may consume that capacity, leaving leaders progressively less able to respond elsewhere.
Restraint without gradual surrender
Avoiding escalation is a legitimate strategic objective.
Diplomacy, patience and compromise can sustain stability and create opportunities for agreement. The challenge is to distinguish deliberate restraint from an incremental acceptance of restrictions that undermine the policy being protected.
The debate about NATO’s response thresholds illustrates this institutional problem.
Consultation and collective defence serve different purposes. Between them, governments must decide how to address accumulated harm while retaining control over escalation. The wider lesson applies beyond any alliance: recognising hostile activity does not automatically produce an agreed, timely response.
There is a second danger.
Repeated economic and political pressure may teach participants that their opponents will tolerate more. Each side can become confident that the next measure will remain manageable. Yet earlier restraint does not guarantee future restraint. Miscalculation becomes more likely when assumptions about tolerance replace careful assessment.
For states maintaining relationships across competing powers, preserving options therefore requires both preparedness and communication. Protective measures should support diplomacy by reducing vulnerability, while clear communication helps prevent reassurance from being interpreted as unlimited tolerance.
Evidence must guide the assessment
Not every repeated difficulty is threshold conditioning.
Technical faults, commercial disputes, administrative failures and unrelated political decisions can produce cumulative harm without coordinated hostile intent. International investment and cultural interaction should not become suspect merely because they create influence.
A credible assessment needs evidence of a pattern, an identifiable response threshold being exploited, and consequences that accumulate over time. It also needs a reasoned judgement about coercive intent.
Analysts should test alternative explanations and distinguish what they observe from what they infer.
Resistance belongs in the evidence too.
If access stays available, replacement capacity improves, or pressure fails to change decisions, the assessment must reflect that. An adversary's persistence does not establish success. Confidence about disruption may be high while confidence about responsibility remains low.
Acting while choices remain
The first requirement is an agreed reference point.
Governments and businesses need to know what normal access, delivery times, service reliability and decision speed look like. The benchmark should not shift automatically whenever pressure persists. Otherwise, yesterday’s restriction becomes tomorrow’s definition of normality.
Risk registers should record the cost of recovering an option, as well as the direct financial loss.
A restriction that appears affordable today may require years of investment to reverse. That difference should influence how urgently leaders respond.
The second requirement is a shared assessment.
Existing diplomatic, security, regulatory and commercial teams can connect their findings without creating another large institution.
Their task is to explain what has changed, which explanations fit, what is still unclear and who has authority to act.
Third, responses ought to address the vulnerability identified.
These measures can preserve choices even before responsibility for disruption is established.
A graduated approach to response sustains political judgement.
Improving resilience does not require the same evidence as publicly attributing a hostile campaign. Sanctions and military measures require their own legal and evidentiary foundations.
Keeping these decisions distinct allows early protection without turning suspicion into automatic escalation.
Exercises should test the time between recognising deterioration and authorising action. Include ambiguous evidence, competing commercial interests and disagreement among partners. An option that exists on paper may become unusable if approval takes longer than circumstances permit.
Measure success by restored choices. Can an essential service continue? Can a company switch providers in time? Can a government maintain lawful access and pursue its chosen policy? Warnings have strategic value when they improve those outcomes.
The period before a crisis is therefore a matter for active policy, not simply observation.
Relative calm can coexist with declining preparedness, access, and autonomy.
The task is to identify that deterioration honestly and respond proportionately. By the time a crisis becomes unmistakable, the decisive question may be how many choices have already disappeared.
Dr John Bruni is founder and CEO of SAGE International, an Australian strategic advisory firm specialising in geopolitics, defence and security. He holds a PhD from the University of New South Wales and has worked across academia, government advisory and international strategic analysis, including as Special Military Adviser to the Emirates Center for Strategic Studies and Research in Abu Dhabi.
This article forms part of the ITT Nexus Invited Expert Perspectives Series, developed and published by ITT Nexus and AcceleratEMEA as part of their official media partnership with AIM Congress 2026.
The views and interpretations expressed are those of the author and do not necessarily reflect the positions of ITT Nexus, AcceleratEMEA, or AIM Congress. The author remains responsible for the accuracy of the information, data, references, and conclusions presented. Publication within this series does not constitute institutional endorsement.
Discover additional contributions from invited experts featured in the ITT Nexus Expert Perspectives Series, published in connection with ITT Nexus and AcceleratEMEA’s official media partnership with AIM Congress 2026.
Receive updates on ITT Nexus research, expert perspectives, publications and upcoming initiatives.
Join a curated series of expert perspectives developed by ITT Nexus and AcceleratEMEA as part of our official partnership with Global Organizations.
ITT Nexus and AcceleratEMEA invite policymakers, investors, executives, academics and industry experts to contribute evidence-based perspectives on the forces reshaping global investment and prosperity. Selected proposals will be featured through expert articles, executive interviews or post-event insights, subject to editorial review.
ITT Nexus - Innovation & Reserch
Copyright © 2026 ITT Nexus- Innovation Think Tank - All Rights Reserved.
Powered by ITT Nexus